Americans would be really insulted if they stopped eating long enough to read any literate publications. Recently, “The Last Bite” by Bee Wilson in The New Yorker and “Indians Find U.S. at Fault in Food Costs,” in The New York Times insinuated that our gluttony contributes to the suffering of one billion starving people. Although Wilson’s article about food politics, provocatively subtitled “Is the world’s food system collapsing?” is too theoretical to cause us any personal embarrassment, it does hit hard with observations such as:
- “… our insatiable demand for food must be worn on our bodies, often in the form of diabetes as well as obesity. Overeating makes us miserable, and ill, but medical advances means that it takes a long time to kill us, so we keep on eating.”
Translation: At least smoking killed us fast and we didn’t use so much gas to get us where we’re going.
The Times article, however, gets right to the point. It quotes Pradeep S. Mehta, Secretary General of CUTS, an independent research institute in New Delhi, who suggested that if Americans slimmed down to the weight of middle -class Indians “many hungry people in sub-Saharan Africa would find food on their plates.”
Whew!! Talk about bad timing. Just when fat Americans — 70 percent of us — managed to convince the media and medical experts that obesity is a disease, this guy comes along and upsets our apple cart. How rude! But can’t we find it in our big hearts to forgive him? After all, living in New Delhi, he hasn’t had the opportunity to avail himself of American political correctness training. He just doesn’t know what our Presidential candidates have learned: you have to be nice to fat folks. On the campaign trail when addressing an audience of huge beings, they would never be as boorish as to point out that Americans are “driven by our bottomless stomachs,” as Paul Roberts argues in “The Last Bite.” Or even hint at the consequences: forget affordable health care as the obesity numbers climb from 70 to 89% by 2030.
Now the question is how did these rude accusations surface in the land of the free and the fat?
Well, George W. Bush sparked the debate when, during a May 2nd Missouri news conference, he explained that Indians were at fault for higher food prices because some of them now have jobs that pay more than a dollar a day, which means they can buy more food! Immediately after this Bush-league pronouncement, the Asian Age, a New Delhi newspaper, argued in an editorial that Mr. Bush’s “ignorance on most matters is widely known and openly acknowledged by his countrymen.”
What a mess! George Bush — our lame duck President — has gone and spilled the beans. Our fatness is now everybody’s – meaning the world’s — business. Will we ever learn to shut our mouths?
Michael | 17-May-08 at 3:15 pm | Permalink
If anyone needs to shut their mouths, it’s George Bush. His continued arrogance, and wastefulness have only fueled the current crisis. And we’re not only talking about food here.
Bush and the current American regime is a symptom of the larger problem in America - this anti-intellectualism is pervasive, and is causing our problems to leak into India, China, and beyond.
Paulie | 17-May-08 at 6:29 pm | Permalink
Since when do we elect based on ‘intelligence’ ? ?
Oh, perhaps there’s a difference between ‘intellectual’ and ‘intelligent.’ Are those who persist in ‘packing face’ less ‘intellectual’ or is it a basic lack of ‘intelligence?’ or . .
Does being FAT make you STUPID or the other way, ’round?
Glory | 26-May-08 at 3:55 pm | Permalink
So? If we all get skinny, we’re automatically going to get smarter too, right?
Wow! But what about all the fat people who are already wicked smart? Will they, then, be able to take over the world?
Its a good thing they’re exploring Mars and the Moon, because when all these newly thin, super smart former ‘fatties’ get ahold of those who formerly judged them based on body size, we’ll all be shipped out there somewhere. Hope they have the place fixed up by then because I hate being uncomfortable.
Erika | 03-Jun-08 at 3:59 pm | Permalink
A message to Glory; How can someone be wickedly smart and be fat? That’s an oxymoron, smart and fat? The upkeep alone to maintain such a thing is a mathematical conundrum. To be fat is bad for health, if they were so smart—why would they be fat when all scientific studies have shown it’s bad? Obviously—they’re not smart enough.
Bryan James | 03-Jun-08 at 8:55 pm | Permalink
Stupidity makes you FAT, not the other way around. We all know it’s bad (not healthy for us) to be fat yet we do everything that will make us fat.